Subject: partying and drinking

Submitted by: Brian Goldstein, Chevy Chase, MD 


Let me preface my question by saying I love your book and have seen some good results in the relatively short time I've been following the bodybuilding plan (I'm trying to gain some mass). While I read your thoughts on alcohol in NHE, I have a question that is not answered in the book. I always drink alcohol at least once a week when I go out on weekends. I know I'd be better off if I gave it up, but I like to party and drinking is a part of that for me. Since I'm going to do it regardless, I wanted to know if it would it be better to do this as part of a carb up or on a low carb day? I could think of a reason for both. If I drink on a low carb day, I'd get kicked out of ketosis and thus probably mess up the rest of my low carb days until the next carb up. However, if I drink after eating carbs I thought maybe the alcohol will be stored as fat. Thanks in advance for clearing this up for me.


Thanks for the kind words. If your drinking and partying nights fall on a carb-load days (which is actually carb-load evenings given they take place as the last meal(s) of the day), then they can be merged into the carb-load or upcycle. If drinking alcohol fell on a day other than the carb-load and you were on the general NHE Eating Plan, I'd say compensate by keeping carbs lower that day relative to other downcycle days, prior to drinking. But since you are on the bodybuilders' NHE Eating Plan, which allows much less leeway regarding carbs, try to hook it up with the carb load given there's no upward limit on carb intake during the carb-load phase. It terms of scheduling, it would be to your advantage to limit the drinking and partying to one night per week rather than two, so each drinking night would coincide with a carb-load. Also, type of alcohol matters. If you are drinking large amounts of sweet drinks like dacaris or pina colada two nights per week, then you may as well throw-in the towel now because the bodybuilders' NHE Eating Plan is not for you. Something like vodka and club soda/water with a twist would be more advisable.

Also, if you are not taking at least three tablespoons per day of flaxseed oil, you are likely not getting enough fat or good fat. Fish oil is a better source of EPA/DHA, but there are purity issues with fish oil, and flaxseed oil delivers more lipid per dollar. Overall, the bodybuilders' NHE Eating Plan is not only more challenging than the general but also more expensive when you factor in fat supplementation. If you can schedule your drinking/partying for once rather than twice per week, you can transfer those funds into buying a six pack of flaxseed oil.